Analysis: Taxes only symbolic in debt talks so far

Jul 7, 2011, 2:18 p.m.

By Kevin Drawbaugh

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Symbolic gestures and agreements in principle, but not substantive reforms, are likely to be the main tax policy result of urgent talks about raising the U.S. debt ceiling.

As President Barack Obama and congressional leaders met on Thursday, Republicans sounded more flexible on tax breaks with fresh talk of ending ethanol subsidies and tax loopholes for corporate jets, private equity financiers and Big Oil.

While important as political signposts, such steps would barely move the needle on cutting the $1.4 trillion U.S. budget deficit and $14.3 trillion national debt.

A broad overhaul of the tax code, like the one proposed in December by Obama's Simpson-Bowles deficit commission, would be needed for that. But that would take far more time than the 27 or so days that debt ceiling negotiators have to cut a deal.

August 2 is the deadline set for raising the debt limit and preventing the government from defaulting on its borrowings for the first time in U.S. history, an event that could devastate world markets.

President Ronald Reagan and congressional Democrats took two years to get the last comprehensive tax reform to the finish line in 1986.

"We haven't even started the car yet, let alone get it out of the garage," said a top congressional aide on the tax reform project, which most aides and analysts expect will have to wait until late 2012 and into 2013, after presidential and congressional elections in November next year.

The Obama administration is drafting a proposal for tax code changes expected to be released later this year.

A business lobbyist said that a debt-ceiling deal might sketch out "broad parameters" for tax cuts, with details to be filled in later by tax-writing committees of Congress.

Earlier this week, Republicans said they were willing to discuss possibly closing some tax loopholes. Their remarks were seen by some as signs of new flexibility on raising revenue, though Republicans were quick to add they would not support any tax increases.


Taxing private equity fund managers' gains as ordinary income, instead of as capital gains as is done now, would raise $2.2 billion in 2012, or $21.4 billion from 2012 to 2021, according to Congress's Joint Committee on Taxation.

Ending two oil and gas industry tax breaks -- last-in, first-out inventory accounting and expensing of exploration and development costs -- would raise tax revenues by a combined $10.5 billion in 2012, or $107.5 billion over 10 years.

Extending depreciation of corporate jets, according to Republicans on Congress's Joint Economic Committee, would raise $300 million a year, or $3 billion over 10 years.

Three U.S. senators reached a deal on Thursday to repeal the $6 billion per year ethanol tax credit by the end of July, an agreement that must still be passed by Congress. The deal would reduce the federal deficit this year by $1.3 billion.

"We're spending most of our time talking about things that are in the millions and billions, when the real deal comes in the trillions ... That's corporate tax overhaul, changes to the tax structure, changes to entitlements," said Ed Mills, policy analyst at FBR Capital Markets. "A lot of this debate is as much about message as it is about substance."

Most Recent